Source: Journal of the American Holistic Veterinary
Medical Association ; 07/31/1999
Use of Cetyl Myristoleate for Arthritis and Tendonitis in Holistic
Veterinary Medical Practice
by Debra Tibbitts, DVM
I practice holistic medicine because I believe that
using its concepts and natural compounds, I can, not only treat
illnesses and acute problems, but can improve the overall health of the
animal. While practicing conventional veterinary medicine, I became
disillusioned with the way I was taught to treat animals. I had many
patients who responded well to conventional treatments and drugs, and
they would be in good condition for two, three, even six months.
However, it seemed that they would always be back in for the same
problem or an even more severe one. Drugs used for treatment of
conditions like arthritis seemed to pose more of a risk for potential
harm with long term use, than a solution.
I attended all of the veterinary conferences l could, and after learning
about the latest, greatest things in treatment and drugs, I soon
discovered that there was not much of a difference between the outcomes
using current methods of treatment and the outcomes achieved using the
newer treatments. In my practice, I have always seen a significant
amount of arthritis, mostly in dogs, so treatments and natural compounds
targeting arthritis and its manifestations have been of particular
interest to me. About 90% of the arthritis I see is osteoarthritis,
along with some immune-mediated problems such as lupus and rheumatoid
arthritis.
I was always on the lookout for something better with which to treat my
patients. I initially read about cetyl myristoleate (CM) in a
JAHVMA ad, and, after receiving further information, I started using CM
in the fall of 1998. Since then, I have placed a total of 21 animals on
CM, and the results have ranged from good to astounding. One of my most
recent cases is a Lab, Jake, that has a one-year history of progressive
stiffness and soreness. After he was given two rounds of CM, the owner
called and said, "Jake ran a couple of miles with no soreness or
stiffness. What should I do?" Happily, I was able to advise her
that, if the dog is normal, she could stop the CM.
Typically, the owner expects improvement, but they do not expect the
total improvement that they see with CM (Myristin®, see footnote 9
below). This article will provide background on CM and report on six
specific cases in which the product was used successfully, and one case
where therapeutic results were not seen.
Research and Discovery of CM
CM is a fatty acid ester of myristoleic acid, a common fatty acid found
in fish oils, whale oils, dairy butter, and animal fats. CM is also
found in the fruits of Myristica kombo, which is tropical nutmeg, but
rarely used as it is a more expensive source material. Myristoleic
acid is a mono-unsaturated, medium chain fatty acid with a molecular
weight of 450. Chemically, it is the hexadecyl ester of tetradecenoic
acid (myristoleic acid).
Cetyl myristoleate was a new compound to science when discovered in 1964
by Harry W Diehl, an experienced medical researcher, who was employed at
the time by the National Institute of Arthritis, Metabolism, and
Digestive Diseases at the National Institutes of Health. Mr Diehl was an
accomplished researcher, having discovered an improved method of making
the sugar 2-deoxy-d-ribose, which was patented by the government and
subsequently used by Dr Jonas Salk as the culture medium for his polio
vaccine(1). CM was a project of personal interest for Mr Diehl, not a
government sponsored effort. His motivation for researching CM is really
quite interesting and altruistic. Like many older Americans, Diehl
himself fell victim to osteoarthritis in his hands, heels, and knees.
His heels were so painful he could hardly walk.
Diehl's doctor gave him cortisone injections, but it reached a point
where cortisone was no longer advisable, and the doctor told Diehl that
there was nothing else to do but take NSAID's. At that point, he was
eighty years old and decided to make a batch of CM to try on himself,
which successfully cured him of all symptoms of his arthritis.(6,7)
Mechanism of Action
No one knows for sure what the exact mechanism of action of CM is. This
is a familiar answer when it concerns dietary supplements, and, for that
matter, many pharmaceutical compounds as well. With one-half of the
molecule coming from a fatty acid, CM shares properties of the essential
fatty acids, but its effects seem to work faster and last longer against
arthritis, than the EFAs.
Dr Charles Cochran has written, "Some authors and practitioners
believe that cetyl myristoleate has the ability to reprogram faulty
memory T-cells, thus treating the cause of arthritis [in the case of
rheumatoid types of arthritis]. I have not found this to be totally
correct. Cetyl myristoleate may have the ability to normalize
hyper-immune responses, thus [producing] the favorable results in
treating autoimmune conditions such as rheumatoid arthritis and systemic
lupus erythematosus, but it seems to function more effectively as a
lubricant and a powerful anti-inflammatory."(8)
Use of Cetyl Myristoleate in Seven Animals
In November, 1998, I decided to try CM on my patients. I elected to use
CM in accordance with the distributor's recommendations. In
general, most of the animals tolerate the CM oil and the support formula
well when the capsules are opened and the contents spread on the
animal's food. Animals fed once daily, receive their daily dose all at
one time. For animals taking two daily feedings, the dose of CM and
support formula can be divided. I have not had to give three or four
courses to any small animals.
All animals treated have done well with one or two bottles. Of course,
one bottle may last longer for some animals than for others. Some of the
larger dogs, and some of the more severely afflicted, have taken a
second bottle. I have treated an arthritic horse with CM. She was given
about 150 capsules (three bottles), at the rate of six capsules daily,
and her arthritis was greatly improved.
In cases where owners have allowed us or someone else to do diagnostic
x-rays, where we can be sure of the diagnosis, the results have been
excellent. In most of these cases, the animals are walking normally,
including our tendon cases. The only ones that have not done well are
the ones on which a comprehensive diagnostic workup was not done, and we
were assuming that arthritis was the cause of the lameness.
Nevertheless, the results from using CM surpass the owner's
expectations.
Clinical Cases
Here are seven specific cases from my practice that will illustrate
various conditions and the response to treatment with cetyl
myristoleate:
Taffy, 1987 Golden Retriever, first seen 12-30-97, for a painful left
rear leg and early urinary incontinence. Her left stifle was enlarged
and painful. No radiographs were obtained. She was placed on yucca twice
a day for the stifle pain and was also switched over to a natural dog
food. She did well, but still had some stiffness upon rising. On
11-12-98, Taffy had become acutely lame on her left front leg the day
before and was worsening. Radiographs were taken and revealed arthritic
changes in the shoulder and elbow joints. On 11-16-98, Taffy was started
on CM, 1 in the morning and 2 at night, along with the joint support
formula, 3 in the morning and 3 at night. On 11-20-98, the owner
reported Taffy was doing great, not even stiff when first getting up in
the morning. On 12-3-98, the owner reported Taffy was just fine and done
with her medication. As of 5-99, Taffy has had no further treatment for
her arthritis and is still moving normally.
Cocoa, 1992 Australian Shepherd-Lab mix, first seen 3-23-98, with a
history of previous trauma to hip causing deformity of the femoral head
and neck, with secondary arthritis in both hips. She was placed on a
natural pet food, a multi-vitamin, vitamin C, and yucca. On 4-27-98, the
owner reported that the right hip seemed worse. On 5-2-98, Cocoa had
inflammation along spine. Radiographs revealed narrowed disc spaces at
L5-6 and L6-7, along with worsening of right hip. Cocoa was placed on an
anti-oxidant combination, a glucosamine combination product, and a boron
and calcium combination along with the yucca. Cocoa seemed a bit
improved but had recurrent diarrhea from medications. On 10-16-98, a
magnetic pet bed was added to the regimen. On 11-24-98, Cocoa was placed
on CM and joint support formula. No further medication has been given
since then, only the magnetic pet bed is still in use, and Cocoa is no
longer stiff or lame as of 5-99.
Emmitt Smith, 1995 Miniature Dachshund, first seen 12-18-98, for
degenerative disc disease that had been non-responsive to prednisone. He
had proprioceptive deficits and partial paresis in the rear legs;
overall grade II disc disease. He was given a magnetic pet bed,
phenylalanine for pain, and CM and joint support formula. He was also
referred for acupuncture treatment. He also had to be given an enema due
to severe constipation. The owner did not change to natural pet food. On
12-23-98, he had decreased propriceptive deficits and increased
strength, but was still tense and painful. He was still not having bowel
movements on his own, so another enema was given. On 12-28-98, the owner
reported some improvement: having bowel movements on his own and resting
better. On 1-4-99, the owner reported that Emmitt was doing great --
very active, no pain medications for four days. On 1-18-99 and 2-18-99,
Emmitt was still doing well. As of 5-99, Emmitt has done well except for
one episode of vomiting and paresis on 2-26-99.
Jake, 1990 Rottweiler, first seen on 1-6-98, for severe, non-responsive
hypothyroidism. He was placed on a holistic protocol for thyroid, and
yucca for stiffness. On 3-25-98, he was placed on glucosamine
combination for stiffness along with yucca and vitamin C. On 5-15-98,
radiographs and joint tap revealed degenerative joint disease, and an
anti-oxidant combination was added to the treatment regimen. On
12-10-98, Jake continued to have good days and bad days, with thyroid
and stiffness problems. He was started on CM and joint support formula.
On 12-23-98, Jake seemed less stiff according to his owner. On 12-30-98,
the owner reported Jake was less stiff and more energetic. The owner
picked up a second bottle of CM. On 4-16-99, there was waxing and waning
of symptoms with a lack of energy. Jake was severely lame on the left
front leg, with a swollen elbow. His abdomen and liver were distended,
skin and haircoat poor. Blood work revealed the thyroid level was
decreased again, with an increase in muscle enzymes, cholesterol and
lipase. He was started on Armour thyroid, with no further treatment for
degenerative joint disease at this time.
Anna, 1994 Australian Shepherd, first seen 12-8-98, for chronic
tendinitis/bursitis of one-year duration. She had been on Rimadyl, which
helped, but then seemed to feel better, be active, and become lame
again. Radiographs revealed no bony changes. She had decreased weight
bearing on the affected leg, toed out when standing on it, was lame at a
walk, had slight pain on palpation of the elbow medially, but had no
inflammation or swelling. She was placed on devil's claw, vitamin C, and
joint support formula. On 12-8-98, very little progress was noted, and
the dosage of vitamin C and devil's claw was increased. On 12-21-98, she
was switched to yucca instead of devil's claw. On 12-30-98, she was
somewhat better and was restricting activity, but still not a lot of
improvement. On 1-4-99. her diet was changed to natural fermented pet
food. On 1-18-99, she was started on CM and salmon oil along with joint
support formula. On 2-16-99, the owner reported Anna was feeling her old
self again, running and doing well. On 3-17-99, she had one episode of
lameness after wrestling with other dogs and was normal in two days with
no medication. She has been fine since, as of 5-99.
Jake, 1993 Labrador Retriever, first presented 2-24-99, with a one-year
history of getting sore the day after exercise and then fine. The month
prior to presentation, he was stiff and sore a few hours after exercise
and the following two days. At the time of presentation, he needed help
getting up after exercise. On examination, his left rear leg was painful
and stiff. Radiographs revealed a decreased range of motion of the left
rear leg, hip dysplasia, and mild to moderate arthritis. Jake was placed
on CM and joint support formula along with a change to natural pet food
and limited exercise. The dosage was started out slowly due to
gastrointestinal upset after sedation. On 3-15-99, the owner reported
Jake was doing better; he limped but was improving. They were out of
medication, but will pick up more. On 4-9-99, the owner reported Jake
was doing well; he ran a couple of miles with no soreness or stiffness.
He was still taking medication, but they were almost out. Owner felt
that Jake was 100%.
Max, 1990 Brittany Spaniel, presented 2-25-99, with a history of being
diagnosed with severe hip dysplasia at Washington State University four
years previously, at which time hip replacement surgery was recommended.
I started Max on CM and joint support formula and natural fermented pet
food. On 3-4-99, the owner reported Max was doing excellently, moving
better, and not panting nor groaning. On 3-19-99 Max was doing great! On
4-1-99, we stopped CM and joint support formula, and Max is still doing
marvelous.
What's Ahead?
Animals that were started on their course of CM in the fall of 1998 are
still doing well and have not had to go back on the product since.
Jake's owner was so happy with the results of CM that she put her other
dog on it, and then she put herself on it, too. She also reported that
she overdid physical activity on one weekend and was practically
crippled. After two days of taking CM she was back to normal. With a
product offering so much benefit to animals and humans alike, with no
known toxicity or side effects, there is at last something new for
arthritis to add to our practice as holistic veterinarians. In my
opinion, CM is an incredible product for arthritis. It has become our
optimum choice for chronic tendinitis, as well as arthritis. I also use
magnetic pet beds for hip dysplasia and secondary arthritis in
conjunction with CM, but have not recommended magnetic beds for chronic
tendinitis cases.
I try to give my owners an overview of the different programs they can
put their pets on, and most of them select the CM approach because they
realize that in the long run it is much less expensive and gives
long-term improvement. I look forward to even more long-term successes
using CM and am trying it on different cases, including degenerative
myelopathy in dogs and chronic tendon problems in horses. This is a
product that could be a life saver for many suffering animals. With no
known side effects or toxicity associated with CM, it is not just
another drug to help ease the pain of arthritis and other
musculoskeletal disorders. It can prevent the formation of arthritis and
improve the overall health of the animal. Furthermore, since the animals
do not need to be continually using CM to deal with the arthritis, the
animals are happier, and so are the owners.
Footnotes:
(1.) Gorman, Pat, NIH News, National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, MD.
May 21, 1974, pg 3
(2.) Diehl, Harry W, unpublished paper, Rockville, MD, March, 1971
(3.) Nutrition and Healing, Newsletter by Dr Jonathan Wright, Aug, 1996,
pg 5
(4.) Cochran, Dr Charles, TESLA: A Journal of Modern Science, 3rd Qtr,
1997, pg 1
(5.) Diehl, H and May, E, Cetyl Myristoleate Isolated from Swiss Albino
Mice: An Apparent Protective Agent against Adjuvant Arthritis in Rats,
Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences, March, 1994, pg 296
(6.) Wright, Jonathan, Op Cit, pg 6
(7.) Movius, Edward G, MD, FACP, Gaithersburg, MD, personal letter, Dec,
1991
(8.) Cochran, C, Dr Charles Cochran Discusses Arthritis and Cetyl
Myristoleate Healing, Wisdom Publications, 2067 Broadway, New York, NY
10023, 1996, pg 19
(9) Experience of Dr. Tibbitts is based on Myristin®, a particular
brand of cetyl myristoleate.
|